At regular intervals, the team reflects on how to become more effective, then tunes and adjusts its behavior accordingly.

—Agile Manifesto

 

Iteration Retrospective

The Iteration Retrospective is a regular meeting where Agile Team members discuss the results of the iteration, review their practices, and identify ways to improve.

At the end of each iteration, Agile Teams that apply Scrum (and many teams who use Kanban) gather for an Iteration Retrospective, where the team members discuss their practices and identify ways to improve. Timeboxed to an hour or less, each retrospective seeks to uncover what’s working wellwhat isn’t, and what the team can do better next time.

Each retrospective yields both quantitative and qualitative insights. The quantitative review gathers and evaluates any metrics the team is using to measure its performance. The qualitative part discusses the team practices and the specific challenges that occurred during the last iteration or two. When issues have been identified, root cause analysis is performed, potential corrective actions are discussed, and improvement stories are entered into the Team Backlog.

Details

The Iteration Retrospective is used by Agile Teams to reflect on the Iteration just completed and to derive new ideas to improve the process. This helps instill the concept of relentless improvement—one of the pillars of the SAFe Lean-Agile Mindset—in the individuals and the team. And it helps ensure that every iteration yields some small improvements in the team’s process.

The whole team participates in the retrospective, with the Scrum Master facilitating and applying the tools and processes for data collection and problem-solving. The team conducts the retrospective in two parts: quantitative and qualitative.

Quantitative review: The team assesses whether they met the Iteration Goals. This is a binary measure: yes or no. They also collect any other metrics they agreed to analyze. This must include velocity—both the portion that is available for new development, and the portion devoted to maintenance. Agile Teams collect and apply other Iteration Metrics for visibility and to help with process improvement. This data is also the context for the qualitative section that follows.

Qualitative review: First the team reviews the improvement stories they had identified in the prior retrospective, and then analyzes the current process, with a focus on finding one or two things it can do better in the next iteration. Since many improvement items have significant scope, the team should divide them into smaller improvement stories, so that they can focus on what they can improve during an iteration.

As organizations move closer to implementing the Continuous Delivery Pipeline and DevOps, Agile teams will have a robust list of improvement opportunities, including but not limited to:

  • Test automation and continuous integration
  • Architectural approaches for decoupling development from deployment
  • Automating the deployment process
  • Building telemetry and recovery techniques into systems

Lean-Agile Leaders are responsible for preserving and protecting the time teams will need during each Program Increment (PI) to focus on cultivating these skills, in addition to delivering new features. The Innovation and Planning (IP) Iteration is a great time to create opportunities for teams to advance their skill levels in these new domains.

Retrospective Formats

There are several popular techniques for eliciting subjective feedback on the success of the iteration (also see footnotes [1], [3], [4,], [5]):

  • Individual – Individually write Post-Its, and then find patterns as a group.
  • Appreciation – Note whether someone has helped you or helped the team.
  • Conceptual – Choose one word to describe the iteration.
  • Rating – Rate the iteration on a scale of one to five, and then brainstorm how to make the next one a five.
  • Simple – Open a discussion and record the results under three headings.

The latter is a common method, in which the Scrum Master simply puts up three sheets of paper labeled What Went WellWhat Didn’t, and Do Better Next Time, and then facilitates an open brainstorming session. It can be conducted fairly easily, making all accomplishments and challenges visible, as illustrated in Figure 1.

Figure 1. One team’s retrospective results

Teams may choose to rotate the responsibility for facilitating retrospectives. If this is done, one of the fun practices is to allow each person to choose their own retrospective format when it’s their turn to lead. This not only creates shared ownership of the process, but it also keeps the retrospective fresh. Team members are more likely to remain engaged when formats are new and different.

Guidelines

Below are some tips for holding a successful iteration retro:

  • Keep the meeting time boxed to an hour or less. Remember, it will come up every two weeks. The goal is to make small, continuous improvement steps.
  • Pick only one or two things that can be done better next time and add them as improvement stories to the Team Backlog, targeted for the next iteration. The other targets for improvement can always be addressed in future iterations if they continue to surface in retrospectives.
  • Make sure everyone speaks.
  • The Scrum Master should spend time preparing the retrospective, as it’s a primary vehicle for improvement.
  • Focus on items the team can address, not on how others can improve.
  • To show progress, make sure improvement stories from the previous iteration are discussed either at the Iteration Review, or at the beginning of the quantitative review.
  • This is a private meeting for the team and should be limited to Agile Team members only (Development Team, Scrum Master, and Product Owner).

 

Learn More

[1] Derby, Esther and Diana Larson. Agile Retrospectives: Making Good Teams Great. Pragmatic Bookshelf, 2006.

[2] Leffingwell, Dean. Scaling Software Agility: Best Practices for Large Enterprises. Addison-Wesley, 2007.

[3] Fun Retrospectives. www.funretrospectives.com

[4] TastyCupcakes.org. http://tastycupcakes.org/tag/retrospective/

[5] Agile Retrospective Resource Wiki. http://www.retrospectivewiki.org

 

Last update: 14 June, 2017